On May 29th the government responded to the proposals of the Dutch National Climate Assembly. The government was very positive on the assembly itself. As prime minister Rob Jetten told the assembly participants that were present: politicians can learn from the constructive way the participants have worked together. "You are a mirror for all the MPs, and the cabinet. If you can do it, why can't we?". Other ministers handed out compliments as well, telling the assembly that citizens can reach agreement on big problems, even if opinions vary widely.
The ministers also expressed they were impressed with the specific proposals of the assembly. However, looking at the proposals of the French Climate Assembly (2019) one could tell that citizens' assemblies are willing to go a lot further than governments and elected politicians. To a large extent, we see the same dynamics here: actual implementation of the proposals is a different matter. Out of the 82 proposals altogether, only 41 will be implemented, and a number of them were already in the process of becoming government policy anyway. One example of this is making electric cars more accessible by introducing a subsidized trade-in scheme to exchange old petrol or diesel cars for second-hand electric ones. One more example is the guarantee that newly acquired products can be repaired: this has already been agreed upon at the EU level.
23 out of the 81 proposals didn't make it all, among them:
- a black dot on the packaging of unhealthy food
- reducing subsidies on fossil fuels to zero
- a tax on jet fuel
- increasing the percentage of biologically managed agricultural land from currently 4, to 25 percent in 2030
- a complete ban on pesticides
- a CO2 tax on agricultural production
The remaining proposals are still under consideration, among them:
- a tax on fossil plastics
- mandatory increased use of recycled plastics
- supporting farmers to help them switch to biological production
- forcing supermarkets to offer more biologically produced products
- a law against wasting food in restaurants (doggy bags) and in supermarkets, inspired by a similar law that has already been introduced in Spain
Professor Linda Steg (Groningen University), expert on sustainability and behavior, expressed her reservations on the government's response: "On the list of measures I don't really see one clear new policy measure based on the recommendations." She found the actual new commitments made by the cabinet quite open-ended: just some committees and pilots.
However, the process doesn't end here. At a final session in November, the government will discuss with the House and assembly participants how the recommendations will be implemented. Also, assembly participants will keep in touch with the ministers, and the cabinet will provide updates in the two years to come. Some measures just take a lot more time to implement partially or entirely, so it's a bit early to judge.
One of the proposals that will be implemented is a lobbying registry. Although this registry is intented to expose the regular behind-closed-doors lobbying, future citizens' assemblies might consider being registered themselves as lobbyists too. Because, as David Van Reybrouck once stated, that's basically what a lottery-based citizens' assembly is: a lobby for a very important group that does not yet have a lobby: the people itself.
Sources:
- Kabinet neemt helft adviezen burgerberaad klimaat over, wel veel bestaande plannen, NOS Nieuws, 29 May 2026
- Het kabinet omarmt het advies van het burgerberaad. Maar komt het ook met nieuw klimaatbeleid?, Trouw, 29 May 2026
- Kabinet neemt helft advies Burgerberaad Klimaat over, maar schuift omstreden voorstellen door naar Europa, NRC, 29 May 2026
- Kabinet boekt direct resultaat met eerste burgerberaad en neemt de helft van 82 klimaatadviezen over, Nederlands Dagblad, 29 May 2026
- Kabinet 'onder de indruk' van klimaatadviezen burgers, maar schuift helft terzijde, NU.nl, 29 May 2026
- "Your voice has been heard", Mehr Demokratie, 29 May 2026
See also: