In the summer of 2023, the Dutch House of Representatives and the government decided to support a National Climate Assembly focusing on nutrition, consumer goods, and travel. However, the unstable four-party coalition fell, elections followed, and again four parties formed a new government: the big-business oriented VVD, the radical-right PVV, the 'farmer-citizen movement' BBB, and the most reluctant coalition party: the centrist to right-of-center 'new social contract' NSC, lead by former christian-democrat CDA MP Mr. Pieter Omtzigt.
A change of government is not a good thing for getting firm political support for a Citizens' Assembly and its recommendations, but remarkably the National Climate Assembly was not scrapped during the process of forming the new government. The radical-right PVV, the biggest party in the House, is neither a supporter of Citizens' Assemblies, nor of climate policy. Still, the responsible ministers and departments carried on organizing the assembly.
In November 2024, letters were sent to 70,000 citizens selected by lot. Early January this year, as the Climate Assembly really got underway, criticism from right-wing media started, followed by protests on social media, calling on governing parties to put a stop to the assembly. On X radical-right leader and MP Geert Wilders lashed out at the assembly, and BBB MP Henk Vermeer called for an immediate stop to the assembly. However, almost two thirds of the House voted against the request to the government to immediately stop the assembly:

Remarkably the PVV and BBB put the blame for this assembly taking place on parties in the former government — parties now in the opposition — walking away from their responsibity as supporters of their own coalition. The government pushed on, counting on the reluctance of the PVV and BBB to drop support for the coalition altogether. Still, the lack of support from a large part of the bicameral parliament is not a good sign: support for the Climate Assembly was clearly not as widespread as had more or less been claimed by the assembly's chairwoman Nienke Meijer: 'All political parties, both the coalition and the opposition, want to listen more and better to citizens.' Probably the topic of choice, climate policy, wasn't the best possible option to get all polical parties on board.
The amount of attention the Climate Assembly has been getting from the media isn't too bad. Newspapers, radio, and both public and commercial TV stations have reported on it. However, they could have done a better job explaining how the citizens were selected: by lot. Supporters of the radical-right questioned the selection process: who picked these 175 citizens? Were they hand-picked by the organizers, in order to get the 'preferred outcomes' of the assembly? The general public is still unfamiliar with the lottery process, let alone a stratified lottery process, and in everyday speech, the Dutch word geselecteerd, selected, means something totally different than the word geloot, drawn by lot. That the statified lottery was set up in such a way that the assembly mirrored the diverse ways citizens think about climate change, could have gotten a lot more attention, and could have been better explained. There were exceptions though: especially the online newspaper de Correspondent and the centrist newspaper NRC did quite a good job.
In the meantime, main NSC founder Mr. Omtzigt has quit being an MP altogether, in order to finally completely recover from his burn out. He is not the first MP that left the House because of this reason. The last session of the Climate Assembly will be on June 21st en 22nd. After the summer the assembly will had over its recommendations to the government. The government then will have six months to respond to all the individual recommentations: whether they will implement them, and if not, why they won't implement them. Especially about this implementation phase Eva Rovers, one of the main Dutch Citizens' Assembly advocates, expressed worries.
Sources:
- National Climate Assembly official website
- Een nationaal burgerberaad moet burgers inspraak geven in klimaatbeleid van het kabinet
de Volkskrant, 19 January 2025 - Speciaal burgerberaad gaat maatregelen tegen klimaatveranderingen bedenken
NOS.nl, 18 January 2025 - Een select groepje Nederlanders mag het kabinet adviseren omtrent klimaat − ‘Ik vind het ook fijn om verre reizen te kunnen maken’
NRC, 18 January 2025 - Het Nationaal Burgerberaad Klimaat gaat van start! De impact ervan is aan ons
door Eva Rovers, de Correspondent, 17 januari 2025 - Burgerberaad: 175 Nederlanders geven de minister klimaatadvies
Trouw, 17 January 2025
See also: